Hive vs Shortcut——どっちが優秀？
Hiveを選ぶべき人: メール機能とAI機能を内蔵した、モダンなオールラウンダーが欲しいスピード重視のチーム
Shortcutを選ぶべき人: Trelloを卒業したがJiraは息苦しい — 10〜100人のエンジニアにちょうどいいスイートスポット
私たちの見解: Hive is easier to pick up, but Shortcut is more powerful long-term.
| Hive | Shortcut | |
|---|---|---|
| 料金 | Free for up to 10 users | Teams $18/user/mo | Free for up to 10 users | Team $8.50/user/mo |
| 機能 | Gantt, kanban, and calendar views, Native email integration, Time tracking and resourcing, AI-powered task summaries, Proofing and approvals | Kanban and timeline views built for dev sprints, Deep GitHub, GitLab, and Sentry integrations, Docs and wikis inside the project tool, Iteration planning with velocity tracking, Milestones that group epics across teams |
| こんな人に最適 | Fast-moving teams that want a modern all-rounder with built-in email and AI features | Software teams that outgrew Trello but find Jira suffocating — the sweet spot for 10-100 engineers |
| 学習コスト | 簡単 | 普通 |
本当の違い
Both offer free tiers, so the real question is what you get when you start paying.
Hive stands out with Gantt, kanban, and calendar views and Native email integration. Shortcut counters with Deep GitHub, GitLab, and Sentry integrations and Docs and wikis inside the project tool.
Hive's Achilles heel: pricing jumps hard from free to paid — $18/user/mo with no mid-tier option. Shortcut's: non-technical teams struggle with the developer-centric terminology and workflow assumptions. Pick whichever weakness you can live with.
結論
If you value gantt, kanban, and calendar views and メール機能とai機能を内蔵した、モダンなオールラウンダーが欲しいスピード重視のチーム, go with Hive. If trelloを卒業したがjiraは息苦しい — 10〜100人のエンジニアにちょうどいいスイートスポット matters more, Shortcut is your pick. Neither is a bad choice — but one will fit your workflow better.