Adobe XD vs Spline — Mana yang Lebih Unggul?
Pilih Adobe XD jika: Tim yang sudah berlangganan Adobe Creative Cloud dan membutuhkan desain UI/UX dasar
Pilih Spline jika: Desainer web dan front-end developer yang menginginkan 3D di situs mereka tanpa menyentuh Blender atau Unity
Pendapat kami: Adobe XD for simplicity, Spline for power users.
| Adobe XD | Spline | |
|---|---|---|
| Harga | No free plan (included in Creative Cloud $54.99/mo) | Single App $9.99/mo (legacy) | Free with unlimited projects and community sharing | Pro $7/mo |
| Fitur | Prototyping and wireframing, Repeat grid, Auto-animate, Voice prototyping, Creative Cloud integration | Browser-based 3D modeling with real-time collaboration, 3D animations and interactive scenes without code, One-click embed for websites and React apps, Material editor with PBR and custom shaders, Built-in physics engine for interactive prototypes |
| Terbaik untuk | Teams already paying for Adobe Creative Cloud who need basic UI/UX design | Web designers and front-end devs who want 3D on their sites without touching Blender or Unity |
| Tingkat kemudahan | Sedang | Sedang |
Perbedaan Sesungguhnya
Both offer free tiers, so the real question is what you get when you start paying.
Adobe XD stands out with Prototyping and wireframing and Repeat grid. Spline counters with Browser-based 3D modeling with real-time collaboration and 3D animations and interactive scenes without code.
Adobe XD's Achilles heel: adobe effectively abandoned it — no major updates since 2023, figma won the market. Spline's: not a replacement for serious 3d work — geometry tools are basic compared to blender or cinema 4d. Pick whichever weakness you can live with.
Kesimpulan
If you value prototyping and wireframing and tim yang sudah berlangganan, go with Adobe XD. If desainer web dan front-end matters more, Spline is your pick. Neither is a bad choice — but one will fit your workflow better.